Worksheet
A Loss, Two Ways of Telling
Compare an original chess story and short play, analyzing how scene boundaries, dialogue, pacing, and endings shape meaning and style.
Grade 8ELAInteractive · Printable
Aligned toRL.8.5
What’s included
- Single worksheet
- Auto-graded online
- 1 Common Core standard
- Printable answer key
- 14 questions
- Classroom-ready
Details
- Format
- Interactive · Printable
- Grade
- Grade 8
- Subject
- ELA
- Question types
- Multiple choice, Circle the answer, Short answer
About this worksheet
What students practice
- Students compare how a story and a play arrange the events surrounding the same chess match.
- Students analyze how pacing, dialogue, and scene boundaries contribute to meaning and style.
- Students support structural comparisons with specific evidence from both texts.
How to use
Read both texts, then answer the paired analysis and evidence questions. Discuss how each text controls what readers experience directly.
Curriculum
Common Core standard covered
Compare the structures of two or more texts and analyze how each structure adds to its meaning and style.
Preview
OwlSheets.com
A Loss, Two Ways of Telling
Compare how a story and a short play shape the meaning of the same chess match.
Read both texts
Both original texts concern Tesni's chess match against her older brother, Nalin. No knowledge of chess rules is needed. Bracketed words in the play are stage directions.
Text A: Her Side of the Board
1Tesni set the chess pieces on the recreation center's folding table while Nalin hung his jacket over a chair. Usually, their games became lessons before she had finished deciding what to do. Tonight she placed a small card beside the board: NO ADVICE UNLESS ASKED. Nalin read it, smiled uncertainly, and sat down. Tesni wished he had argued. Then she could have delivered the speech she had practiced on the walk over.
2Their opening moves passed quickly. Without Nalin's running explanations, the room sounded unexpectedly large: shoes squeaked beyond the door, and someone dragged a chair across the floor. Tesni developed a plan to attack along one side of the board. Before each move, she almost looked up for his reaction. Instead, she studied the pieces. For the first time, the silence between turns belonged partly to her.
3Halfway through the game, Nalin reached toward a piece, stopped, and glanced at the card. Tesni saw the warning in his face. Her hand hovered above her rook. She could ask one small question without tearing up the agreement. But a question now would really mean, Tell me which move is safe. She moved the rook. Nalin captured it on his next turn. Heat climbed into her cheeks, and the hallway noises seemed suddenly sharp.
4She expected him to explain the mistake. He folded his hands beneath the table. Tesni spent a long time examining the remaining pieces, then made another move. They played on. She found one useful attack and lost it, protected another piece, and missed a chance she noticed too late. At last she tipped her king onto its side. The little wooden knock was less dramatic than the ending she had imagined.
5Nalin began putting away the pieces. Tesni picked up the fallen rook before he could reach it. She placed it where it had stood before her mistake and asked him to show her what she had overlooked. He sat back down. They examined two possible moves, arguing over the second until Tesni saw why it failed. When she reset the board for another game, she straightened the card beside it. Nalin left his jacket on the chair.
Text B: Leave the Board
1Scene One: Clearing Up. [A recreation center. A chess game has just ended. TESNI's king lies on its side. NALIN gathers pieces into a box. A card beside the board reads NO ADVICE UNLESS ASKED.] NALIN: You stayed in longer this time. TESNI: That sounds like something you say to a person learning to float. NALIN: I meant— TESNI: I know. [She takes her rook from the box and sets it on the board.] Leave the board. NALIN: We can play tomorrow. TESNI: I didn't say leave the room.
2Scene Two: Putting It Back. [The box remains open. TESNI moves the rook to another square.] TESNI: Here. This is where everything went wrong. NALIN: Before that, actually. TESNI: Then put it back before that. [He replaces several pieces. She corrects the position of one pawn.] NALIN: You remember where that was? TESNI: I was playing too. [He withdraws his hand.] TESNI: When you stopped moving your hand, I knew you wanted to warn me. NALIN: I did. TESNI: I wanted to ask. I didn't want the answer.
3NALIN: Those sound like the same thing. TESNI: Not tonight. [She tries a different move.] What happens here? [He moves a piece in reply. She studies the board, then returns both pieces to their previous squares.] TESNI: And here? NALIN: That keeps your rook, but look at the other side. [She leans over the board.] TESNI: Oh. [A chair scrapes in the hallway. Neither looks toward the door.] NALIN: I could have shown you during the game. TESNI: Then this would be your mistake that I avoided.
4Scene Three: Setting Up. [TESNI begins returning the pieces to their starting squares. NALIN closes the empty box.] NALIN: Same rule? TESNI: Same rule. NALIN: And afterward? TESNI: Afterward I might ask. NALIN: You might win. TESNI: I might lose without giving you a lesson to teach. [He opens his mouth, then shuts it. She waits until he meets her eyes.] NALIN: Fair enough.
5[NALIN reaches for his jacket, pauses, and lets it fall against the chair.] NALIN: Your move. [TESNI checks the rows of pieces. She straightens the card and moves a pawn. NALIN studies the board without speaking. TESNI's hand rests beside the open space where the box had been. Beyond the door, the hallway grows quiet. Neither player reaches for the fallen pieces from the previous game; all of them are standing now.]
Structure and evidence
Choose one answer for each multiple-choice question. For underline questions, choose one complete sentence. Consider what each text presents directly and what it leaves readers to reconstruct.
- A. It makes her request seem like an attempt to change the result of the match.
- B. It makes her request seem like a choice she can make without surrendering independence.
- C. It makes her request seem like a return to letting Nalin direct each turn.
- D. It makes her request seem like a condition Nalin required before agreeing to play.
- A. Tesni hears shoes beyond the door; later, the hallway noises seem especially sharp.
- B. Tesni begins an attack on one side; later, Nalin gathers the pieces into their box.
- C. Tesni prepares a speech before arriving; afterward, Nalin hangs his jacket over a chair.
- D. Tesni completes the match without advice; afterward, she chooses a position to examine with Nalin.
- A. The difficulty Nalin has remembering the agreement beside the board.
- B. The distraction that prevents Tesni from seeing her brother's warning.
- C. The conflict between accepting guidance and owning a risky decision.
- D. The advantage Tesni gains by making Nalin wait for her next move.
Halfway through the game, Nalin reached toward a piece, stopped, and glanced at the card.Tesni saw the warning in his face.Her hand hovered above her rook.She could ask one small question without tearing up the agreement.But a question now would really mean, Tell me which move is safe.She moved the rook.
- A. Readers follow whether Nalin can persuade Tesni to admit who won the match.
- B. Readers follow whether the siblings can negotiate how to play and learn together.
- C. Readers follow whether Tesni can prevent Nalin from capturing her rook.
- D. Readers follow whether Tesni can remember enough moves to reverse the result.
- A. “You stayed in longer this time.” / “That sounds like something you say to a person learning to float.”
- B. “Here. This is where everything went wrong.” / “Before that, actually.”
- C. “Same rule?” / “Same rule.” / “And afterward?” / “Afterward I might ask.”
- D. “What happens here?” / “That keeps your rook, but look at the other side.”
- A. Their disagreement becomes a shared investigation that Tesni helps direct.
- B. Their conversation becomes a lesson that proceeds without Tesni's input.
- C. Their conversation becomes a rehearsal of moves they must use next time.
- D. Their disagreement becomes a contest over whether Nalin actually won.
[The box remains open.TESNI moves the rook to another square.][He replaces several pieces.She corrects the position of one pawn.][He withdraws his hand.]
- A. Text A's sequence follows a private struggle; Text B's scenes make the relationship visible through exchanges.
- B. Text A's sequence creates emotional distance; Text B's scenes explain feelings through a narrator.
- C. Text A's sequence resembles a match report; Text B's scenes resemble instructions for learning chess.
- D. Text A's sequence stresses the rules of chess; Text B's scenes stress the accuracy of remembered moves.
- A. Text A places a card beside the board; Text B prints the same card's message in a stage direction.
- B. Text A mentions hallway sounds during play; Text B includes a scraping chair during discussion.
- C. Text A describes Nalin's jacket on a chair; Text B shows him leaving his jacket in the room.
- D. Text A gives Tesni's unspoken reasoning; Text B develops disagreement through replies and gestures.
- A. The movement from discussing their relationship to testing a revised understanding.
- B. The opportunity to discover why Tesni wanted to ask for advice during play.
- C. The explanation that Tesni lost a rook before losing the completed match.
- D. The contrast between Tesni's memory of the board and her brother's memory.
- A. Tesni identifies a mistake; Nalin places pieces; Tesni corrects the location of a pawn.
- B. They discuss help after a game; they agree on the rule; they begin playing under it.
- C. Nalin offers praise; Tesni challenges its wording; Nalin begins an explanation.
- D. Nalin gathers pieces; Tesni retrieves a rook; they reconstruct the earlier position.
Develop a comparison
Explain how arrangement creates an effect, rather than simply listing events or naming text types.
Related worksheets
WorksheetGrade 8
Words Across the Table
Reading: Literature · RL.8.5
Premium14 questions
WorksheetGrade 8
One Hallway, Several Centers
Reading: Literature · RL.8.5
Premium14 questions
WorksheetGrade 8
One Project, Two Story Structures
Reading: Literature · RL.8.5
Premium14 questions
WorksheetGrade 8
The Repair Counter: From Story to Film
Reading: Literature · RL.8.7
Premium13 questions
WorksheetGrade 8
An Ingredient Not Listed
Reading: Literature · RL.8.9
Premium13 questions
WorksheetGrade 8
Before the Replay
Reading: Literature · RL.8.3
Free14 questions