OwlSheets
Homework: Where Should the Limit Be? worksheet preview

Worksheet

Homework: Where Should the Limit Be?

Analyze how sentences and paragraphs build an argument about homework limits, including benefits, concerns, responses, and a proposed plan.

Grade 6ELAInteractive · Printable

Aligned toRI.6.5

What’s included

  • Single worksheet
  • Auto-graded online
  • 1 Common Core standard
  • Printable answer key
  • 13 questions
  • Classroom-ready

Details

Format
Interactive · Printable
Grade
Grade 6
Subject
ELA
Question types
Multiple choice, Circle the answer, Short answer

About this worksheet

What students practice

  • Students analyze how individual sentences develop an informational argument.
  • Students explain how paragraphs connect and contribute to an article's overall structure.
  • Students evaluate how acknowledging concerns strengthens a proposed solution.

How to use

Have students read and annotate each paragraph's purpose before answering. Discuss how removing or moving a paragraph would change the argument.

Curriculum

Common Core standard covered

RI.6.5

Analyze how a sentence, paragraph, chapter, or section fits the overall structure and develops the ideas.

Preview

OwlSheets.com

Name Date

Homework: Where Should the Limit Be?

Analyze how the parts of an argument work together.

Read and Examine the Opening

Read the article. For each question, consider what a part of the text does, not just what it says.

Homework: Where Should the Limit Be?

1Imagine finishing a math assignment, opening a reading response, and then remembering a vocabulary sheet. Each teacher may have assigned a reasonable task, yet the combined workload can fill an evening. For a student who also has family responsibilities or an afternoon activity, that pile presents a difficult choice. Should schools judge homework only assignment by assignment, or should they consider the whole evening?

2Homework can serve a useful purpose. A few carefully chosen problems give students a chance to practice a new method without immediate guidance. A short reading response can show a teacher where understanding breaks down. These tasks also give students experience planning work independently. Removing all homework would remove opportunities like these, so the debate should distinguish useful practice from work assigned simply to fill time.

3The difficulty begins when additional work offers little additional learning. Once a student can explain a method, completing many nearly identical problems may reveal little more. Consider two assignments: one asks students to solve several different problems and explain their choices; the other repeats the same kind of problem across several pages. Counting completed pages would make the second assignment look stronger, even if the first reveals more understanding.

4A homework limit raises a fair concern: students work at different speeds. One student may finish a task quickly while another needs longer to think through it. A flexible stopping point, paired with a note explaining where the student struggled, could preserve practice without demanding an unlimited evening. The teacher could then use that note to decide what support to provide the next day.

5Making such a limit work would require coordination. Teachers could use a shared assignment calendar to notice when several major tasks fall on the same evening. They could also identify which parts of an assignment are essential and which provide optional practice. Students would need clear instructions about recording unfinished work honestly. A limit without these routines would be a rule on paper rather than a workable classroom plan.

6Schools do not have to choose between empty backpacks and evenings crowded with assignments. They could test a coordinated, flexible limit and review the quality of student work alongside feedback from families. The question would then become more useful than whether students had done enough pages: did the work reveal learning worth the time it required?

1.
How does paragraph 1 prepare readers for the argument?
  • A. It defines several types of homework before comparing their difficulty.
  • B. It presents an everyday situation that leads to a question about policy.
  • C. It gives research findings that establish the effects of evening assignments.
  • D. It outlines a classroom procedure that the remaining paragraphs explain.
2.
Which sentence in paragraph 1 moves from the imagined situation to the policy question identified in Question 1? Underline one sentence.

Imagine finishing a math assignment, opening a reading response, and then remembering a vocabulary sheet.Each teacher may have assigned a reasonable task, yet the combined workload can fill an evening.For a student who also has family responsibilities or an afternoon activity, that pile presents a difficult choice.Should schools judge homework only assignment by assignment, or should they consider the whole evening?

3.
Why does the author include paragraph 2 before discussing homework's drawbacks?
  • A. To establish that reading assignments deserve more time than math assignments.
  • B. To describe the steps teachers follow when grading independent assignments.
  • C. To suggest that students should decide which assignments teachers collect.
  • D. To acknowledge homework's value before arguing for changes to its use.
4.
Which sentence most directly supports the answer to Question 3 by connecting homework's value to the debate about limits?
  • A. “Removing all homework would remove opportunities like these, so the debate should distinguish useful practice from work assigned simply to fill time.”
  • B. “For a student who also has family responsibilities or an afternoon activity, that pile presents a difficult choice.”
  • C. “Counting completed pages would make the second assignment look stronger, even if the first reveals more understanding.”
  • D. “Teachers could use a shared assignment calendar to notice when several major tasks fall on the same evening.”

Trace the Connections

Return to the article to analyze examples, concerns, and proposed solutions.

5.
How does the opening sentence of paragraph 3 connect to paragraph 2?
  • A. It replaces the earlier discussion of learning with a history of homework.
  • B. It explains why the earlier examples apply mainly to younger students.
  • C. It shifts from homework's possible benefits to the limits of extra practice.
  • D. It summarizes the earlier examples before adding another similar benefit.
6.
In paragraph 3, what does the comparison between the two assignments contribute?
  • A. It provides a sequence teachers can follow when creating a worksheet.
  • B. It illustrates why the amount of work may not show its learning value.
  • C. It explains why written explanations are easier than repeated problems.
  • D. It establishes that longer assignments require more difficult thinking.
7.
How is paragraph 4 organized?
  • A. It states a concern about a limit and then offers a way to address it.
  • B. It compares two school policies and then selects the more popular one.
  • C. It lists causes of unfinished work and then ranks them by importance.
  • D. It describes an unsuccessful plan and then explains why it was ended.
8.
Which sentence in paragraph 4 introduces the response to the concern, rather than stating the concern or describing a later teacher action? Underline one sentence.

A homework limit raises a fair concern: students work at different speeds.One student may finish a task quickly while another needs longer to think through it.A flexible stopping point, paired with a note explaining where the student struggled, could preserve practice without demanding an unlimited evening.The teacher could then use that note to decide what support to provide the next day.

9.
How does paragraph 5 develop the proposal introduced in paragraph 4?
  • A. It reports results showing that the proposal has succeeded in schools.
  • B. It shifts responsibility for the proposal from teachers to families.
  • C. It argues that assignment calendars should replace flexible stopping points.
  • D. It describes routines needed to put the proposal into daily practice.

Evaluate the Whole Structure

Consider how the order of the article builds its argument. Support your written response with details.

10.
What does the final question in paragraph 6 contribute to the conclusion?
  • A. It introduces a separate debate about how students should receive grades.
  • B. It asks families to calculate the number of pages students finish each night.
  • C. It gives readers a standard for judging homework by learning rather than quantity.
  • D. It settles the concern about different work speeds by recommending equal assignments.
11.
Which outline best represents the article's overall structure?
  • A. A workload question → benefits and drawbacks → a concern and response → practical steps and a proposed test
  • B. A workload question → a history of assignments → results from school experiments → a prediction about future classes
  • C. A classroom problem → competing student interviews → a comparison of school rules → a vote on the best policy
  • D. A classroom problem → instructions for doing homework → examples of completed work → advice about improving grades
12.
An editor suggests adding this sentence: “For example, teachers might move a small assignment when the calendar already shows a major project deadline.” Where would it fit best?
  • A. After the sentence about vocabulary homework in paragraph 1.
  • B. After the sentence about independent planning in paragraph 2.
  • C. After the sentence about different work speeds in paragraph 4.
  • D. After the sentence about a shared assignment calendar in paragraph 5.
13.
Suppose an editor removed paragraph 2. Explain how that change would affect both the fairness of the argument and the connection to paragraph 3. Use details from the article.

Related worksheets