OwlSheets
← Exit

Rails or River? A Prairie Town Decides, 1851

0 / 10

Rails or River? A Prairie Town Decides, 1851

Weigh both sides of a council debate and use a described map and data on canals, railroads and the telegraph.

The map and the data

Read the map description and the table. Then answer the questions.

Described map: Willow Ford, Illinois, in 1851 (Willow Ford is an invented town.)
1. Willow Ford sits on the Illinois River, about 30 miles downriver (southwest) of LaSalle.
2. LaSalle is where the Illinois and Michigan Canal, opened in 1848, meets the Illinois River.
3. The canal runs about 100 miles northeast from LaSalle to Chicago, on Lake Michigan. From Chicago, ships sail the Great Lakes east toward New York.
4. Below Willow Ford, the Illinois River flows southwest into the Mississippi River above St. Louis, Missouri.
5. A railroad company plans a line from Willow Ford east across the prairie to join the new Illinois Central Railroad, which will connect to Chicago.
Linking the Regions (rounded estimates)
YearU.S. railroad milesNew York City to Chicago
1830about 23about 3 weeks
1840about 2,800—
1850about 9,000—
1857—about 2 days
1860about 30,000—
1.
Use the described map. In 1851, which route would a boat carrying Willow Ford's wheat take to reach Lake Michigan?
Question 1 options
2.
Use the table. Count 1 week as 7 days.

The 1857 trip from New York City to Chicago took about fewer days than the 1830 trip.

3.
Use the table. During which ten years did the United States add the most miles of railroad?
Question 3 options
4.
Draw a line from each link to the way it connected regions, based on the map and the speeches below.

The council debates

Read the council minutes. The meeting and the speakers are invented, but the facts about canals, railroads and the telegraph are real.

Minutes of the Willow Ford Town Council, October 1851

1In 1850, Congress gave Illinois a large grant of public land to help build the Illinois Central Railroad. Towns across the prairie now argued over whether to pay to bring a line to their own streets. At Willow Ford, the railroad company offered to lay track to the town if the town bought $40,000 of the company's stock. The council met to decide.

2Councilman Amos Treadwell spoke first. "The river and the canal have served us well, but only for part of the year. From about December to March the canal freezes, and our wheat sits in barns while prices in Chicago rise and fall without us. A train runs in January as well as July. By rail, our wheat could reach Chicago in less than a day. By boat and canal it takes the better part of a week."

3"Think also of the farmers on the prairie east of town, twenty miles from any river," Treadwell went on. "They haul wheat to our landing by wagon over roads that turn to mud each spring, or they do not grow wheat to sell at all. The new line would run right past their fields. And the telegraph company will string its wire beside the track. Today we learn Chicago and New York grain prices days late from the newspapers. With a telegraph office here, we would know them the same morning."

4Councilman Ezra Lindqvist answered. "I do not doubt that trains are fast. But forty thousand dollars is more than this town collects in taxes in many years. A canal boat carries a ton of grain for much less than a railroad charges today. The river and the canal already join us to Chicago and the Great Lakes to the north, and to St. Louis and New Orleans to the south. Why pay for what we have?"

5"And who says the company will finish?" Lindqvist asked. "Railroad companies have gone bankrupt and left half-built track rotting on the prairie, and the towns that bought their stock lost their money. If we wait, perhaps a richer company will build the line for nothing."

6After two hours of debate, the council voted 5 to 2 to buy the stock. The track and the telegraph wire reached Willow Ford in 1855.

5.
Sort each piece of evidence by the speaker who used it.
6.
After 1855, how would the telegraph office most likely help a wheat farmer near Willow Ford?
Question 6 options
7.
Which part of Willow Ford's geography gave Lindqvist his strongest argument against paying for the railroad?
Question 7 options

Weigh the decision

Use the map, the table and the minutes.

8.
A farmer lives on the prairie twenty miles east of Willow Ford, next to the new track. How did the railroad most likely change his choices after 1855?
Question 8 options
9.
The table shows railroad miles more than tripling from 1850 to 1860. What does this suggest about debates like the one in Willow Ford?
Question 9 options
10.
Did the Willow Ford council make a wise choice? Make a claim, support it with at least two pieces of evidence from the map, the table or the minutes, and explain your reasoning. Answer one argument from the other side.