OwlSheets
← Exit

A Merchant's Road to Annapolis, 1786

0 / 11

A Merchant's Road to Annapolis, 1786

Follow a described map and a traveler's journal to find the Articles' weaknesses, then weigh the compromises of 1787.

The journey

Read the described map and the journal. Elias Mercer and his journal are invented; the places, distances, events and laws are real. Then answer the questions.

Described map: Elias Mercer's route, September 1786
1. Hartford, Connecticut, on the Connecticut River, where the trip starts.
2. New York City, about 110 miles southwest of Hartford. Congress met here under the Articles of Confederation.
3. New Brunswick, New Jersey, about 30 miles southwest of New York City.
4. Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, on the Delaware River, about 60 miles southwest of New Brunswick.
5. Annapolis, Maryland, on Chesapeake Bay, about 120 miles southwest of Philadelphia.

From the Journal of Elias Mercer, Merchant

1September 2, 1786, Hartford. I loaded my wagon with cheese, onions and a crate of tinware to sell along the road south. My brother Jonah came to see me off. He served six years in the Continental Army, and Congress paid him partly in paper certificates that promised payment later. But Congress cannot tax anyone; it can only ask the states for money, and many states send little. Last spring Jonah sold his certificates to a speculator for a small part of what they promised.

2September 6, New York City. Congress meets here in City Hall, but a clerk told me that on many days too few delegates come to do any business. At the docks, customs officers collected New York's duty on a cargo of English cloth. A Connecticut shopkeeper who buys that cloth will pass the tax on in his price, yet the money goes to New York. Sailors say British soldiers still hold forts on the Great Lakes, three years after the peace treaty promised to remove them, and Congress has no army to make them leave.

3September 8, New Brunswick, New Jersey. The innkeeper grumbled that most foreign goods reach New Jersey through the ports of New York and Philadelphia, so his neighbors pay import taxes to New York on one side and to Pennsylvania on the other.

4September 10, Philadelphia. I sold my cheese, but the buyer paid in Pennsylvania paper money, which merchants back home will take only at a loss. Each state prints its own money. At the coffeehouse, merchants were angry that Britain has closed its West Indies islands to American ships. "If Congress could shut our ports to British ships until Britain opened hers, London would listen," one said. "But Congress has no power over trade, and each state makes its own rules."

5September 14, Annapolis, Maryland. A meeting called to discuss trade between the states ended here today. Only twelve delegates from five states came, too few to act. Before leaving, they asked every state to send delegates to Philadelphia next May to make the national government strong enough for the country's needs. Among them were James Madison of Virginia and Alexander Hamilton of New York.

6September 17, 1787, Philadelphia. A year later I am back in Philadelphia. Since May, delegates from twelve states have met behind closed doors at the State House. Today they signed their plan for a new constitution. It gives Congress the power to collect taxes and to regulate trade between the states and with other nations. It creates a president to carry out the laws and a system of national courts, and it forbids the states to print their own paper money.

1.

Use the described map. Add the distances between stops. Elias's route from Hartford to Annapolis covered about miles.

2.
Draw a line from each stop to the weakness of the Articles that Elias saw there.
3.
Years later, James Madison wrote that New Jersey, placed between Philadelphia and New York, was compared to "a cask tapped at both ends." Use the New Brunswick entry. What did the comparison most likely mean?
Question 3 options
4.
In 1786, a Virginia tobacco planter wants Congress to force Britain to reopen its West Indies islands to American ships. Based on the Philadelphia entry, why would Congress have trouble doing this?
Question 4 options
5.
Underline the sentence from the Annapolis entry that best shows how the meeting led to the Constitutional Convention.

6.
Use the whole journal. Sort each rule: was it true under the Articles of Confederation, or under the Constitution signed in 1787?

Debates behind closed doors

Use the table and the journal.

Note: Southern states such as Virginia, South Carolina and Georgia earned much of their income by shipping crops such as tobacco and rice overseas. The trade-law and slave-trade compromises were settled together in one bargain in August 1787.
Four Debates at the Constitutional Convention, 1787
IssueOne side wantedThe other side wantedCompromise
Seats in CongressLarge states: by populationSmall states: equal votesHouse by population; Senate 2 per state
Trade lawsSouth: two-thirds vote, no export taxNorth: simple majority voteMajority vote; no tax on exports
Slave tradeDeep South: keep the slave tradeMany others: let Congress ban itNo ban allowed before 1808
Choosing the presidentCongress choosesThe people vote directlyElectors equal to state's Congress seats
7.
Use the note and the table. Why did many Southern delegates want to ban taxes on exports?
Question 7 options
8.

Use the table. Under the compromise on choosing the president, a state with 2 senators and 8 representatives would have electors.

9.
Use the table. Which statement best describes how the convention settled the debates over seats, trade laws and the president?
Question 9 options
10.
Use the note and the table. Who paid the heaviest price for the bargain over trade and the slave trade, even though they had no voice at the convention?
Question 10 options
11.
Claim: "The problems Elias saw on his 1786 journey explain why the Constitution gave Congress power over taxes and trade." Do you agree or disagree? Make your own claim, use at least two pieces of evidence from the map, the journal or the table, and explain your reasoning.