Worksheet
Before the Capsule Closes
Read an original time-capsule story and distinguish strong textual evidence from details that support weaker or broader claims.
Grade 8ELAInteractive · Printable
Aligned toRL.8.1
What’s included
- Single worksheet
- Auto-graded online
- 1 Common Core standard
- Printable answer key
- 14 questions
- Classroom-ready
Details
- Format
- Interactive · Printable
- Grade
- Grade 8
- Subject
- ELA
- Question types
- Multiple choice, Circle the answer, Short answer
About this worksheet
What students practice
- Students cite the strongest textual evidence for direct statements and inferences.
- Students evaluate whether a conclusion goes beyond what the story's details establish.
How to use
Have students read the story independently and mark relevant details. Discuss why a true detail may still be weak evidence before students write their final responses.
Curriculum
Common Core standard covered
Cite the evidence from the text that most strongly supports what it says directly and what can be inferred from it.
Preview
OwlSheets.com
Before the Capsule Closes
Weigh details carefully to support direct statements and inferences.
Read and investigate
Read the story. For each question, distinguish what the text establishes from what a reader might assume.
The Seam in the Picture
1The class time capsule stood on a table: a metal box fitted inside a wooden case the students had built. Tamsin had measured every panel twice. Tomorrow, the case would enter a storage alcove behind the school office, labeled for a class twenty years ahead. Today, everyone had one last chance to approve the contents.
2Tamsin spread out the class photograph. A crooked strip of tape joined two prints where the printer had run out of paper. “I can replace this before tomorrow,” she said. Beside it lay a description of an ordinary school day, copied neatly from the class's suggestions. She had removed crossed-out words and straightened the margins. The page looked ready for someone important.
3Idris read the description, then searched the scrap-paper tray. He pulled out the original sheet, where “the hallway is loud” had been crossed out and replaced with “the hallway is quiet.” Underneath, another student had written, “Depends when you get there.” “That line was mine,” Idris said. Tamsin explained that the final version said the hallway changed throughout the day, which included both ideas. “It includes the answer,” he said, “but not how we got there.”
4Idris placed the rough sheet beside the neat copy. The capsule's inventory lay under a ruler. A square of afternoon sunlight reached across the table. He pointed to three different handwriting styles around the crossed-out sentence. “Someone opening this might think one person decided what our days were like,” he said. He left the sheet on the table and went to help attach the case handles.
5Tamsin lifted the rough page. One corner had a purple thumbprint from the day their pens leaked. She remembered arguing that the hallway was quiet because she arrived before most students. Until Idris mentioned it, she had forgotten that her sentence had started the disagreement. She put the rough sheet beneath the neat one, with both edges showing.
6At the final check, Jalen asked whether they should vote on replacing the photograph. Tamsin studied the strip across its middle. It crossed her own face, but everyone remained visible. “Leave it,” she said. On the inventory, she added: “Class photograph, printed in two parts after the paper ran out.” Then she invited everyone to check her descriptions of their objects.
7As the others read, Tamsin rested the lid against the case. Jalen found that his woven bookmark had been listed as a wristband, and she corrected the entry. She did not ask anyone to rewrite the rough page. When Idris returned with the screws, she handed him the inventory and waited while he read it.
- A. It makes the hallway sound quieter than students remember it.
- B. It includes handwriting that future students may struggle to read.
- C. It hides the different contributions behind the finished account.
- D. It gives too much attention to differences in students' arrival times.
Idris placed the rough sheet beside the neat copy.The capsule's inventory lay under a ruler.A square of afternoon sunlight reached across the table.He pointed to three different handwriting styles around the crossed-out sentence.“Someone opening this might think one person decided what our days were like,” he said.He left the sheet on the table and went to help attach the case handles.
- A. Another student adds “Depends when you get there” to the original sheet.
- B. She explains that the final version says the hallway changed throughout the day.
- C. She remembers arriving before most of the other students reached school.
- D. Idris finds three handwriting styles around the crossed-out sentence.
- A. The claim is weakened because Idris distinguishes the answer from the discussion.
- B. The claim is supported because Idris finds a correction on the original sheet.
- C. The claim is weakened because Idris prefers the original sheet's handwriting.
- D. The claim is supported because Tamsin removes the students' crossed-out words.
Weigh the evidence
Choose the strongest evidence, not simply a detail that concerns the same object or character.
- A. She remembers classmates agreeing with her description of the hallway.
- B. She has forgotten why the class decided to describe an ordinary day.
- C. She has confused the hallway disagreement with the day the pens leaked.
- D. She has overlooked her own part in the discussion preserved on the sheet.
Tamsin lifted the rough page.One corner had a purple thumbprint from the day their pens leaked.She remembered arguing that the hallway was quiet because she arrived before most students.Until Idris mentioned it, she had forgotten that her sentence had started the disagreement.She put the rough sheet beneath the neat one, with both edges showing.
- A. She keeps both sheets together and records why the photograph has two parts.
- B. She measures every panel twice and studies the tape across the photograph.
- C. She straightens the margins and remembers the day the students' pens leaked.
- D. She rests the lid against the case and gives Idris the completed inventory.
- A. She had measured every panel of the wooden case twice.
- B. The case was labeled for a class twenty years ahead.
- C. The capsule would be stored behind the school office.
- D. The students had one last chance to approve the contents.
- A. The claim fits because Tamsin decides against replacing the photograph.
- B. The claim goes too far because Tamsin retains the neat copy alongside the rough one.
- C. The claim goes too far because Jalen, rather than Tamsin, suggests a vote.
- D. The claim fits because the strip of tape crosses Tamsin's own face.
- A. Tamsin invites everyone to check the descriptions of their objects.
- B. Tamsin waits while Idris reads the inventory after returning with screws.
- C. Tamsin adds an explanation of the photograph's two-part printing.
- D. Tamsin corrects the entry that identifies Jalen's bookmark as a wristband.
- A. He considers the final photograph the capsule's most valuable object.
- B. He believes the corrected inventory contains no remaining errors.
- C. He continues working on the capsule after raising his objection.
- D. He wants to replace Tamsin as the person managing the contents.
- A. He identifies his own line and points to different handwriting styles.
- B. He helps attach the handles and later returns with the screws.
- C. He reads the description and then searches the scrap-paper tray.
- D. He places the rough sheet on the table and explains his concern.
Build a supported reading
Write complete responses. Cite paragraph numbers and quote or precisely paraphrase the strongest details. Explain what each detail establishes.
Related worksheets
WorksheetGrade 8
Room on the Handlebars
Reading: Literature · RL.8.1
Premium14 questions
WorksheetGrade 8
Below the Surface
Reading: Literature · RL.8.1
Premium14 questions
WorksheetGrade 8
Back on the Goal Line
Reading: Literature · RL.8.1
Premium14 questions
WorksheetGrade 8
Words Across the Table
Reading: Literature · RL.8.5
Premium14 questions
WorksheetGrade 8
The Repair Counter: From Story to Film
Reading: Literature · RL.8.7
Premium13 questions
WorksheetGrade 8
One Hallway, Several Centers
Reading: Literature · RL.8.5
Premium14 questions