OwlSheets
← Exit

The Council at Lake Texcoco

0 / 11

The Council at Lake Texcoco

Weigh two sides of an imagined council debate about a dike, then compare how the Maya, Mexica and Inca farmed.

A city in a lake

Read the passage. Then answer the questions.

Farming on the Water

1In about 1325 the Mexica, the people often called the Aztecs, founded the city of Tenochtitlan on a swampy island in Lake Texcoco. The lake lay in the Valley of Mexico, a high basin more than 2,000 meters above sea level and ringed by mountains. Rivers from the mountains drained into the lakes, but no river carried water out to the sea. The water in the eastern part of the lake was salty, while springs fed fresher water into the lakes to the south.

2The island had little dry land, so the Mexica, like other peoples of the valley, farmed on the water. To make a chinampa, farmers staked out a long, narrow plot in shallow fresh water, wove a fence of reeds and branches around it, and piled up layers of mud and rotting plants inside. They planted willow trees along the edges, and the trees' roots grew down through the plot into the lake bed. Canals between the plots let farmers travel by canoe, and each year they scooped rich mud from the canal bottoms onto their beds. Chinampas grew maize, beans, squash, chiles and flowers, and they could produce more than one crop a year.

3As the city grew to perhaps 200,000 people (estimates vary), the Mexica reshaped the lake around it. Long causeways of earth and stone linked the island to the shore. An aqueduct carried fresh drinking water from the springs at Chapultepec on the western shore. Still, the lake could be dangerous. In years of very heavy rain, the water rose quickly, and salty water from the east could spread into the fresher water near the city.

4According to later accounts, a great flood struck in 1449 and covered streets and fields. The ruler Moctezuma I asked for advice from Nezahualcoyotl, ruler of the allied city of Texcoco, who was famous for his building projects. The council scene below is imagined, but the problem the speakers argue about was real.

1.
According to paragraph 1, why did the Valley of Mexico flood easily in rainy years?
Question 1 options
2.
A farmer cuts down the willow trees around the edge of his chinampa. What would most likely happen?
Question 2 options
3.
Sort each action: did it mainly ADAPT to the lake as it was, or CHANGE the lake?

The council debates

Read the imagined speeches. Then answer the questions.

An Imagined Council, Tenochtitlan, 1449

Acatl, an elder who speaks for the chinampa farmers: "The flood has drowned our beds. When the salty water from the east reaches them, the maize turns yellow and dies, and we must wait for rain to wash the salt away. I ask for a wall across the lake, east of the city, from shore to shore. Let it hold back the high water and keep the salty water on its own side. A wall built once will protect every chinampa for many years."

Tototl, an official who gathers workers and tribute: "A wall across the lake will take thousands of workers carrying stone and cutting wooden stakes in the mountain forests. Those workers must come from our allied towns, and they will be gone from their own fields at planting time. Then those towns may send less maize, and our markets will have less food. I say we raise our chinampa beds higher with new mud, strengthen the causeways, and keep our labor for the fields."

4.
Sort each piece of evidence by the speaker who uses it.
5.
What goal do BOTH speakers share?
Question 5 options
6.
Circle the sentence from Tototl's speech that names a cost the wall would have for OTHER towns.

What happened: According to later accounts, the rulers chose to build a long dike of stone, earth and wooden stakes across the lake, east of Tenochtitlan. Thousands of workers from the valley built it. It held back floodwaters and kept much of the salty eastern water away from the fresher water around the city for many years, though later floods still struck.
7.
How does the "What happened" note connect to the debate?
Question 7 options

Three peoples, three environments

Use the table to answer.

Farming Difficult Land in the Americas
PeopleEnvironmentSome farming methods
Maya (height about 250–900 CE)Lowland forest, thin soil, dry seasonMilpa plots, raised fields, reservoirs
Mexica (about 1325–1521)High valley lakes with little dry landChinampas, causeways, a dike
Inca (about 1400–1532)Steep mountains, cold nightsTerraces, canals, freeze-dried potatoes
Milpa plots were cleared, farmed for a few years and then left to rest so the soil could recover. Inca farmers made chuño, freeze-dried potatoes that could be stored for years. Note: Some historians think heavy forest clearing, together with long droughts, helped weaken some Maya cities around 800–900 CE. Others think wars and other causes mattered more.
8.
Draw a line from each problem to the method that answered it.
9.
A people farms steep hillsides where heavy rains carry soil away. Which method from the table would help them most?
Question 9 options
10.
Based on the note under the table, which statement about the Maya is best supported?
Question 10 options
11.
If you were on the council in 1449, would you vote for the wall across the lake? Make a claim, use at least two pieces of evidence from the passage or the speeches, and explain how the lake's environment shaped your choice.