OwlSheets
← Exit

Six Hours or Half a Million Years: How Larkin City's Water Sources Change

0 / 12

Six Hours or Half a Million Years: How Larkin City's Water Sources Change

Use reservoir, cave and sinkhole data to compare fast and slow changes to the land.

Granite Lake is filling up

Read the planning board notes and Graph 1, then answer the questions.

Planning Board Notes: Granite Lake and the East Wells

1Larkin City, a city of about 85,000 people in the hills of the southeastern United States, gets its water from two places. Most of it comes from Granite Lake, a reservoir that formed behind a dam on the Tolan River in 1960. Water flowing through the dam also spins turbines that make about a fifth of the city's electricity. The rest comes from wells in limestone east of town. This year the planning board is writing a 50-year plan for water and energy, and city engineer Ms. Henrietta Vu asked two seventh graders on the youth council, Pilar Ndiaye and Kasimir Oyelowo, to study how the land around these water sources is changing.

2Where the Tolan River enters the still water of Granite Lake, it slows down and drops the sand, silt and clay it carries. The sand has built a delta, a fan of sand that now reaches about 3 km into the upper end of the lake. Finer mud drifts farther and settles over the lake bottom toward the dam. When it was new, the lake held 400 million m³ of water. Every ten years, a boat with sonar maps the lake bottom to find how much of that space sediment has filled (Graph 1).

3In the summer of 2014, a wildfire burned about 20 km² of steep forest above the upper end of the lake. Burned soil soaks up very little water. The next spring, a heavy storm sent debris flows, fast-moving slurries of mud, rock and burned logs, down the bare slopes. In about six hours they carried roughly 2 million m³ of sediment into the lake.

4East of town, the wells draw water from limestone, a rock made from the shells of sea animals that piled up on an ancient sea floor. The limestone is about 400 m thick, lies under much of the region and took roughly 5 million years to build up. Rainwater picks up a little carbon dioxide from the air and soil, which makes it slightly acidic, and it dissolves limestone very slowly as it soaks through cracks. A camera lowered into one well showed a crack that has widened into a channel about as wide as a hand; geologists estimate this took roughly 1,000 years. Under the east side of town, mapped caves have about 20 km of connected passages, which formed over about 500,000 years. Each year the springs carry about 9,000 t of dissolved limestone out of the region, even though their water looks clear. On average, the limestone surface there is being lowered by about 0.05 mm a year.

5In 2022, during a dry summer when the wells were pumping hard and the water table dropped quickly, the ground under a parking lot gave way in less than an hour. The sinkhole was about 12 m wide and 8 m deep. Water filling a hollow underground helps hold up the soil and rock above it.

Graph 1. Sediment Added Each Decade01234561960s1970s1980s1990s2000s2010sDecadeSediment (million m³)
1.

Use Graph 1. By the end of the 2010s, how much of the lake's space had sediment filled in all? million m³

2.
Why is the bar for the 2010s taller than the bars for the other decades?
Question 2 options
3.
In an ordinary decade, the river adds 4 million m³ of sediment, which is 0.4 million m³ a year.

The six hours of debris flows in paragraph 3 added as much sediment as about ordinary years.

4.
Use paragraph 2. Why does sand build up as a delta at the upper end of the lake, while fine mud settles closer to the dam?
Question 4 options
5.
The city will need a new water source once sediment fills 100 million m³, a quarter of the lake. Suppose every decade from now on is ordinary, adding 4 million m³ (0.4 million m³ a year). Start from your answer to question 1.

About how many more years will it take for sediment to fill 100 million m³? years

6.
Suppose a wildfire like the one in 2014 burns the slopes above the lake every 20 years, and each fire is followed by debris flows like those in 2015. How would this change your answer to question 5?
Question 6 options

Under the east side of town

Use paragraphs 4 and 5 of the planning board notes.

7.
The 2022 sinkhole dropped 8 m (8,000 mm) in less than an hour.

At about 0.05 mm a year, dissolving would take about years to lower the limestone surface by 8,000 mm.

8.
Which explanation of the 2022 sinkhole fits the planning notes best?
Question 8 options
9.
Circle every observation that is evidence that slow dissolving, not a sudden collapse, has removed rock from the limestone.

10.
Sort each change by its time and size scale. Fast means a day or less; slow means 10 years or more. Small means less than 100 m across; large means 1 km or more across.

The 50-year plan

Use the whole sheet to answer the questions.

11.
The board can pay for one project now to protect the lake's storage. Which project targets the process that added the most sediment in the shortest time?
Question 11 options
12.
Write a short recommendation for the board's 50-year plan. Make a claim about which changes the plan must watch, give at least three numbers from the notes, Graph 1 or your answers, and explain how processes at very different time and size scales are changing Larkin City's water sources.