OwlSheets
← Exit

By Sea or Over the Alps? Rome, Carthage and the Numbers

0 / 11

By Sea or Over the Alps? Rome, Carthage and the Numbers

Use a passage and three data tables to see how the sea and the mountains shaped trade and war.

The article

Read the magazine article. Then answer the questions.

Two Powers, One Sea

1Rome and Carthage both grew up beside the Mediterranean Sea. Carthage, founded by Phoenician settlers from the city of Tyre, stood on the coast of North Africa. It became a trading power with a strong navy and ports around the western Mediterranean. Rome began as a farming city on the Italian peninsula, a long, narrow land with the Apennine Mountains running down its middle and the high wall of the Alps across its north.

2The sea that connected the two cities also set them against each other. The large island of Sicily lies between Italy and North Africa, only about 90 miles from the African coast near Carthage. In 264 BCE Rome and Carthage went to war over Sicily, the first of three Punic Wars. Rome had little experience fighting at sea, so it built a large fleet and trained thousands of rowers. By 241 BCE Rome had won, and Carthage gave up Sicily.

3In 218 BCE the two powers went to war again. Many historians think that because Rome now had the stronger navy, the Carthaginian general Hannibal chose to reach Italy by land. He marched an army with horses and war elephants from New Carthage in Spain over the Pyrenees Mountains, across southern Gaul and then over the Alps into northern Italy. Snow, narrow paths, steep slopes and attacks by mountain peoples cost him many soldiers and animals. The Greek historian Polybius, who wrote a few decades later, said he had walked part of the route himself to study it.

4Hannibal won great battles in Italy, including Cannae in 216 BCE, and stayed there for about 15 years. Yet he received little help by sea from home, while Roman armies attacked Carthaginian lands in Spain. In 202 BCE the Roman general Scipio defeated Hannibal at Zama in North Africa.

5In peacetime, the same sea carried trade. Merchant ships moved grain, wine, olive oil and pottery between ports all around the Mediterranean. In later centuries the city of Rome came to depend on grain shipped from Sicily, North Africa and Egypt.

1.
Based on paragraphs 1 and 2, why did Sicily become the first prize that Rome and Carthage fought over?
Question 1 options
2.
According to paragraph 3, what do many historians think was the main reason Hannibal marched over the Alps instead of sailing to Italy?
Question 2 options
3.
Circle the sentence from paragraph 4 that shows a cost of fighting far from home, with the sea controlled by the enemy.

The data page

Use the tables and the article.

Table 1. Cost of Moving Goods in the Roman Empire (sea = 1)
Way of moving goodsCost compared with sea
Sea ship1
River boatabout 5
Wagon on landabout 28 to 56
Table 1 is a historians' estimate based on a list of official prices issued in 301 CE, long after the Punic Wars, but historians think the same pattern held earlier.
Table 2. Hannibal's Army (figures given by Polybius)
Point in the marchFoot soldiersHorsemen
After crossing the Rhône River38,0008,000
On reaching Italy, after the Alps20,0006,000
Table 3. Two Journeys (rough distances)
JourneyReported byDistanceTime taken
Hannibal's march, Spain to ItalyPolybiusabout 1,000 milesabout 5 months
Fast voyage, Rome's port to AfricaPliny the Elderabout 370 milesabout 2 days
4.

Using Table 2, about how many foot soldiers did Hannibal lose between the Rhône River and his arrival in Italy? foot soldiers

5.
Which conclusion does Table 2 support best?
Question 5 options
6.

Using Table 1, moving goods by wagon cost at least about times as much as moving them by sea ship.

7.
A Roman merchant wants to send 200 jars of olive oil from a port in Spain to Rome. Based on Table 1 and paragraph 5, how would he most likely send them?
Question 7 options
8.
What do Tables 1 and 3 together suggest about the Mediterranean world?
Question 8 options
9.
Sort each event from the article. Was it an example of peaceful contact and trade, or of conflict?

Make a claim

Use the article and the tables.

10.
Imagine that Carthage, not Rome, had the stronger navy in 218 BCE. Based on the article and the tables, what would Hannibal most likely have done?
Question 10 options
11.
Claim: Hannibal's march over the Alps was a smart use of geography. Do you agree, disagree or partly agree? Give at least two pieces of evidence from the article or the tables, and explain your reasoning.